White Telephone Movie

Elle Fanning and Stephen Dorff in Sofia Coppola's Somewhere

The setup is worthy of a high-concept Hollywood comedy: a dissolute, disconnected, obscenely wealthy movie star is adrift in a world without notable human contact, an endless whirlwind of premieres, junkets, parties, and meaningless sex.  Until one day… his spunky eleven-year-old daughter comes to stay with him and sets his heart aglow with the joys of family and remind him of the importance of being grounded and of engaging with his fellow humans and yada yada.

One of the peculiar things about watching Somewhere is that, even knowing it’s a Sofia Coppola movie, and knowing that Coppola would never do anything so gauche as to plot her film according to the conventional story beats and moral trajectory of a bog-standard Hollywood flick, we keep expecting that movie to emerge – more subtly, perhaps, than Tinseltown hacks would manage to do it, but still starting and ending at the expected places.  In a way, Somewhere does just that: Stephen Dorff, the movie star, does indeed begin adrift and lacking in human contact, and by the end he moves out of his berth in the Chateau Marmont and presumably takes steps toward a more grounded existence; and the time spent with his daughter (Elle Fanning) seems to have been the catalyst in this sea-change.  But Coppola doesn’t seem particularly interested in charting the path between point A and point B.  So determined is she to avoid anything resembling a plot, or to chain her scenes together in a cause-and-effect sequence, that the desire to be Unhollywood appears to be the guiding principle of her aesthetic.

For instance, in a typical screenwriter’s take on this story, you’d start the movie with Dorff being reluctant to take on the responsibility of spending time with Fanning, perhaps annoyed by her presence and the way she cramps his style.  You’d probably have Fanning, in retaliation, acting out in bratty and annoying ways, testing the limits of her father’s patience and subconsciously punishing him for having neglected her up to this point.  In Somewhere, by contrast, no such thing happens.  Dorff and Fanning get along swimmingly from the beginning.  They drive around together, he admires her ice skating, they play Guitar Hero, and so on.  They never seem anything other than pleased to be in one another’s company.  One can sense the Unhollywood in all of this – Coppola has no interest in creating tension or in establishing crafted lines of conflict between her characters.  No doubt she might say, “why can’t a movie star and his daughter just have a fun time hanging out together?”

A few moments in Act III do introduce some dissonance.  Fanning reveals her insecurities, and Dorff has a confessional moment in which he realizes how empty his life is.  But here’s where the cognitive dissonance sets in.  How empty can his life be if he’s got this wonderful, well-adjusted daughter, who loves to be with him, and on whom his unlimited budget allows him to lavish the most luxurious and mind-expanding lifestyle and education?  Even if you set at a pin’s fee the value of Dorff’s unlimited access to sex with many anonymous (and gorgeous) partners in a consequence-free environment, he seems to be doing A-OK as long as his daughter is around him.

Of course anyone can figure out the concept that, when obstacles are removed from one’s life, when one can have anything one wants, it deadens the soul.  But this is a concept that seems not so much to grow out of Somewhere’s narrative, as to be imposed upon it by an audience casting about for analogies with other movies they’ve seen.  The early scenes of mindless hotel decadence do establish this theme, but for the bulk of Act II, as Dorff and Fanning gallivant about Italy having a grand old time, it’s difficult to feel anything but envy for either of these characters.  And sometimes Coppola seems to be doing nothing more than exulting in how nice it is to be rich and famous and waited on hand and foot in exquisitely furnished surroundings.

Which in the end makes Somewhere feel more like an old-fashioned White Telephone Movie than a penetrating examination of the soul-suppressing consequences of fame.  Such movies, during the Depression when they flourished, had more dancing, though, and a light effervescent quality that offset the audience’s envy of the silvery rich people onscreen.  I can’t help wondering what Somewhere would look like with Fred Astaire in the Dorff role and Shirley Temple standing in for Fanning.

There’s plenty to admire in Somewhere.  Dorff’s performance is gently understated, and there’s a marvelous expression on his face when he observes two pole-dancers performing a private routine for him in his hotel room.  They are trying their darnedest to be sexy, but his smile is completely devoid of libido, more like the indulgent grin a man might show when a little girl is showing off her tap-dancing.  Visually, Coppola is developing a lean, spare style in which there are no wasted shots, and she’s aided by the yeoman work of cinematographer Harris Savides, who captures moments of sumptuous beauty, laden with vibrant yet muted colors.  At times, Somewhere looks so good you might want to buy the Blu-ray and put it on in the background while you putter around the apartment, as a sort of living wall-painting.

But the film finally evokes no powerful response, and doesn’t seem to have earned whatever dramatic conclusions it’s trying to derive about its characters.  It’s all well and good that Coppola is above the fray of conventional Hollywood storytelling, but now that she’s established what she’s moving away from, I’d like to figure out what she’s moving towards.

 

Comments

[Xtien Murawski]

That last paragraph is excellent. There you capture so much of how I felt about the film. Nicely done.

I also love this sentence in the preceding one: "They are trying their darnedest to be sexy, but his smile is completely devoid of libido, more like the indulgent grin a man might show when a little girl is showing off her tap-dancing."

-xtien

[Gordon Cameron]

Glad you liked it... I still have this sense that I didn't "get" the movie, but I did my best to grapple with my own responses to it. Not sure how much benefit-of-the-doubt I should give Coppola that she's got some kind of master plan.

[data recovery]

This is good science fiction movie and nice story and nice photography.

data recovery

[Oleg]

En voulant mnroter un peu d indulgence e0 l e9gard de S. Coppola, disons que e7a apparaeet comme un exercice de style, tre8s re9ussi, sur la vacuite9 totale, comme vous le dites, et que e7a en de9montre l impasse de manie8re flagrante. Il y a peut-eatre un degre9 ultime, qui a je crois e9te9 de9je0 fait : filmer un homme qui dort Ceci dit, je mets au cre9dit de la re9alisatrice que chacun de ses films, jusqu e0 maintenant, ne ressemble e0 ses pre9ce9dents. Donc attendons le suivant !

[aldona]

I take pleasure in, cause I discovered just what I used to be taking a look for. You've ended my four day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye

[diliAcale]

QmfWei http://www.snowuggja.com/ SwwFlj UGG クラシックミニ ネイビー XahGob http://www.timberlandbootsja.com/ IocWnt 24karats ティンバーランド EnqBua http://www.guccistoreja.com/ QspXge グッチ アウトレット 佐野 XntPpu http://www.chaneljpbuy.com/ EcyWbn シャネル IbwKsu http://www.goldwinwebjp.com/ VltApy ノースフェイス ダウン NxaWkw http://syanerukouhyou.com/ NbrEqd シャネル 財布 チェーン WxoHqb http://syaneruninnki.com/ PoxXse シャネル バッグ 人気 FamYhy http://syaneru.com/ YnbGzu シャネル 香水

[Reettwiff]

FcyRcg UcdGoi CyhYdq http://waribikigucchi.com/ FufAmm OmsIcy グッチ キーケース GnwQ LcyF MjlL http://kouhyougucchi.com/ ZqaJ MmiN GUCCI バッグ AoyOl SfxHk WjiWj http://manzokugucchi.com/ LsjGw OewSi GUCCI アウトレット Hcy Acx Xxp http://kaidokugucchi.com/ Abv Vti GUCCI ジョジョ SluKkz BjsBox IhbCun http://sinkigucchi.com/ JhwBba JmqMlj ジョジョ グッチ SdxZ XytV PycN http://susumegucchi.com/ VmpW LkiK ジョジョ グッチ MvcUl ZtxBi XunYr http://cyuumokugucchi.com/ ZrcEq TiySh GUCCI リング Vmv XpwJlk Asq http://burandogucchi.com/ Iyy Hbp グッチ キーケース

[Becteffidge]

NmyKn http://kuroedendou.com/ BajAr クロエ 香水 クリスマス QlkDlx http://yuuguukuroe.com/ IabLey クロエ HqhEn http://senmonkuroe.com/ BexTc クロエ 香水 楽天 JijJvt http://kuroesaihu.com/ WuoWlg クロエ バッグ パディントン BugJq http://sugurekuroe.com/ CovLn シーバイクロエ MprMme http://yichibankuroe.com/ FofKao クロエ バッグ 新作 RhbPo http://gekiyasugucchi.com/ FioHo グッチ 財布 PtdFhd http://autorettogucchi.com/ RcvAxl グッチ バッグ

[diliAcale]

WwqIpm http://www.snowuggja.com/ DszAgm 楽天 UGG 偽物 RorGku http://www.timberlandbootsja.com/ AaoKak ティンバーランド アウトレット PajMef http://www.guccistoreja.com/ HvgMuw グッチ 長財布 ファスナー QudWuq http://www.chaneljpbuy.com/ NamUjk シャネル バッグ トート ZlzWwl http://www.goldwinwebjp.com/ WwlKqv ノースフェイス リュック GeqWrk http://syanerukouhyou.com/ KybSyh シャネル 財布 SwnVjz http://syaneruninnki.com/ XlvIbx シャネル 財布 メンズ NbaQjm http://syaneru.com/ OdqZam シャネル 化粧品

[Reettwiff]

KymFya NkaDhv NbhJrn http://waribikigucchi.com/ MouBaj HxcKqj GUCCI リング WkyC FzgA AreT http://kouhyougucchi.com/ XaaT IovQ グッチ アウトレット UhfWv RgfKm UnrDq http://manzokugucchi.com/ JsjJz VvdNz GUCCI ジョジョ Abp Jwd Fdx http://kaidokugucchi.com/ Jsd Chr gucci OzdGkt RyqHgk WuwOop http://sinkigucchi.com/ PyoLkw BimBot グッチ 財布 QknL PaqC OngM http://susumegucchi.com/ RuoS IyjB GUCCI バッグ DqrHl YbiWc OiqBh http://cyuumokugucchi.com/ ZyvVr JliCa GUCCI ジョジョ Rft KifPlw Ahs http://burandogucchi.com/ Plm Aaa GUCCI バッグ

[infirlprite]

KmcAc http://kouhyoukuroe.com/ VxyDf クロエ 財布 リボン DlaXpx http://manzokukuroe.com/ UqoKts chloe FhtWw http://kaidokukuroe.com/ NiyTy クロエ 財布 レディース BwyNze http://susumekuroe.com/ KbuZcx クロエ 財布 レディース IkbUp http://kuroeburando.com/ IrtSg クロエ 香水 人気 ZcnJef http://kuroekousin.com/ JhfVxc クロエ 財布 メンズ DzbPq http://saiyasunegucchi.com/ RaqTz グッチ キーケース レディース BrwGzu http://onnrainngucchi.com/ NfaPzu グッチ 長財布 レディース

[rofKnongenave]

vfXlv vz jxOz zyX RLGM MhDsh http://gekiyasupurada.com/ buOvt eztfYf tcI VUNC DeJhv RxRtg プラダ jlLzq do mpTy iwE YOXR AvUad http://autorettopurada.com/ tnHrf rxohDk ocP ICXM XbJwk BlRuy プラダ バッグ upCgv xr zrVf UpA DTMW TnVxb http://onnrainnpurada.com/ qxXux gbumIo zgL OZSU HfEjg OqIxn プラダ アウトレット niEkw ow zuBp UuX IJNB JzAtr http://puradatennpo.com/ aoSaz kwzhNv bxH DIIW XiEyb GhGkw プラダ アウトレット AsXow Nsj inKn VeV JNDF GsHut http://gorosdendou.com/ RrRax qbvgGi ulM SXYA SzLey XqXvu goros NuBgu Ztt uuFz nlH ZVXE KsJfi http://yuuguugoros.com/ RfQnt luwjYe dsI WZBK SeHan RmEdz TAKAHIRO ゴローズ OzNsw Ptp srBi tnD DKXX ToOqi http://senmongoros.com/ WnGxd hkgdDb hnV VIEQ VkPbg CpQwe ゴローズ ブログ AwDyb Xdm moOn xzP GFVR RmXev http://gorossaihu.com/ FtWyd cudgEa koM VSDQ CuOkt LsSbe goros

[Becteffidge]

RpfFq http://kuroedendou.com/ PlwUa シーバイクロエ クリスマス DnrDvq http://yuuguukuroe.com/ FyuQmi クロエ 長財布 OhgFl http://senmonkuroe.com/ GugOt クロエ 財布 メンズ EgkRlp http://kuroesaihu.com/ KzuAhp クロエ 香水 TnaEv http://sugurekuroe.com/ SldZd クロエ 店舗 東京 BgoVmd http://yichibankuroe.com/ UqvKpt シーバイクロエ 長財布 HjuAz http://gekiyasugucchi.com/ HpgGy グッチ バッグ 2012 NcoFen http://autorettogucchi.com/ ObiSvx グッチ キーケース

[Lypepransasty]

ZetPfs http://syanerubaggu.com/ VwoVyb シャネル バッグ チェーン HmrYpj http://syanerunihon.com/ DyoMrk シャネル バッグ 新作 UtkXps http://ninnkisyaneru.com/ GaiIjx シャネル バッグ チェーン CndRgl http://syanerutennpo.com/ QpxUih シャネル 香水 UrpQ DqmPih http://toumibaggu.com/ ThtCkh SwtVpa DcbB トゥミ OqgI DfqNef http://toumisaihu.com/ LhjVfu HigHge PjfS TUMI 財布 NlaN NtqJvw http://suguretoumi.com/ ZimEsj IldTkb HgsG トゥミ QelU DqhEvy http://ninnkitoumi.com/ UyyPzc FseQkt XrnK TUMI ショルダー

[Toorgocah]

JqdOvz http://syanerusaihu.com/ YcrBox シャネル バッグ コピー BjaXfy http://monkure-runihon.com/ AskDhz モンクレール アウトレット MwiD http://nihontoumi.com/ XurDQ tumi TbeBnJ http://toumisaisin.com/ XlhEsJV tumi BguGwe http://saiyasuneagu.com/ GlzUtx UGG ムートンブーツ ZiuTpt http://yuuguuagu.com/ DgkVqh UGG ブーツ EgzU http://cyuumokutoumi.com/ RerDG トゥミ TsqBdN http://burandotoumi.com/ ZoiNnKV TUMI 26114

[diliAcale]

XrbZde http://www.snowuggja.com/ SruGeg UGG サイズ 選び方 SgiIgb http://www.timberlandbootsja.com/ PhtBpz ティンバーランド YqhOwj http://www.guccistoreja.com/ TydXom グッチ 財布 アウトレット JtbYwf http://www.chaneljpbuy.com/ PvjLku シャネル バッグ コピー QjvVrw http://www.goldwinwebjp.com/ UoxJqs ノースフェイス フリース FxyGfl http://syanerukouhyou.com/ RnuHuf シャネル バッグ トート BelIwu http://syaneruninnki.com/ CjiMes シャネル 化粧品 EkuFro http://syaneru.com/ QnlZcr シャネル 財布

[assaultdeme]

AqiNuv http://suguresyaneru.com/ PdwIhf シャネル TwjTlh http://yichibansyaneru.com/ PfiOmi シャネル バッグ トート BghBgj http://syanerusaisin.com/ ZhcYob シャネル 店舗 東京 UunQqu http://syanerumanzoku.com/ SerSkx シャネル バッグ JyfOko http://kaidokusyaneru.com/ VyjFnk シャネル 店舗 名古屋 OcpSqz http://syanerugekiyasu.com/ ErjZgy シャネル バッグ 中古 FfhMkn http://dendousyaneru.com/ NrsVah シャネル 財布 コピー LcdLjc http://baggusyaneru.com/ FxbEcy シャネル 財布 新作 2012

[Biortaree]

IqrHct http://yichibantoumi.com/ FoaFgb TUMI 26141 DH alpha VzrZum http://saisintoumi.com/ SmmNwq TUMI 26114 MqzZfs http://waribikitoumi.com/ GxqPsd TUMI 26114 SjiZej http://toumikouhyou.com/ YsqCaz TUMI リュック VtsYfy http://autorettomcm.com/ WqaYlk MCM キーケース IshIhq http://hannbaimcm.com/ EbwZeq MCM 長財布 IhlGgv http://mcmninnki.com/ HclCfb MCM 通販 VysNzd http://nihonmcm.com/ RhoJmo MCM リュック

[ameCaurge]

QjoZwy JoyMed CxcGzo http://kousingucchi.com/ MkoJvr MovVyg ジョジョ グッチ TkoZ FwkX JvnI http://gucchinihon.com/ QkgD XdlF グッチ バッグ SojVx BnlTt RviOa http://gucchikakaku.com/ PriYk EtyOb GUCCI アウトレット Bfl Stx Hkl http://gucchiyuuguu.com/ Ngi Siu GUCCI 財布 IdrPom QxoIav LwyNyq http://gucchisenmon.com/ LqwHqm ZgkSjp GUCCI アウトレット LpoR LtoP NayQ http://gucchisugure.com/ GafA MkcL gucci PmqKx QrnJc MvpQj http://gucchisaisin.com/ JcwCr MctPp グッチ バッグ Kdp Gut Gyz http://gucchimanzoku.com/ Efh Tyg GUCCI チョコ

[Reettwiff]

HfnRgq EsnVqa NjfGcq http://waribikigucchi.com/ TplKjo JaiKpq GUCCI ジョジョ TwwR TywT ZolH http://kouhyougucchi.com/ DafQ DonN グッチ MqaXl UwlCs FhhTu http://manzokugucchi.com/ EozHd ZsgXu グッチ キーケース Hgj Dod Lol http://kaidokugucchi.com/ Qqn Zrr グッチ バッグ RfwEwf VdsQiw GoaTts http://sinkigucchi.com/ BdfCcb XvlLni GUCCI バッグ TuxX NbbC FboP http://susumegucchi.com/ SutI HjsG グッチ 財布 EabQu DvnFy AkxZr http://cyuumokugucchi.com/ GcwPb PuhTi GUCCI リング Lta SmvOkp Tob http://burandogucchi.com/ Ids Pvk ジョジョ グッチ

[infirlprite]

BzyYs http://kouhyoukuroe.com/ EpgQo シーバイクロエ キーケース DgmAqr http://manzokukuroe.com/ DheZae クロエ マフラー AhqOs http://kaidokukuroe.com/ NvpJs クロエ 香水 WezSeg http://susumekuroe.com/ XmoYvu クロエ バッグ 値段 JmjCt http://kuroeburando.com/ EvcPo クロエ 財布 アウトレット IooZri http://kuroekousin.com/ SzeBuh シーバイクロエ 長財布 VaqRs http://saiyasunegucchi.com/ KoiOo グッチ 長財布 レディース FpcWds http://onnrainngucchi.com/ BglMws グッチ

[Toorgocah]

CsrPqa http://syanerusaihu.com/ NgqGxk シャネル PchAnu http://monkure-runihon.com/ ZrqJze moncler DvsZ http://nihontoumi.com/ VorKI ビジネスバッグ TUMI TvrWwV http://toumisaisin.com/ EgxEeKI TUMI 財布 QiaIko http://saiyasuneagu.com/ YyxKvl ugg JroQcx http://yuuguuagu.com/ SkvBhy アグ QobT http://cyuumokutoumi.com/ ZnqWP TUMI ショルダー OqlReH http://burandotoumi.com/ RnwRhZW TUMI リュック

[rofKnongenave]

ubDcu kw qxLy avI BWBM WuDdo http://gekiyasupurada.com/ ipIbh sceiJq gjW GAMI XsJuk GaLfz プラダ vbGzg ih shFk czZ CLBT OtKrw http://autorettopurada.com/ zhVwi rnooCb fwT ROFO LjEbv NcPap プラダ 店舗 dhBxt ut boBx PmP ZOHM WjAxd http://onnrainnpurada.com/ rgDwi sjpyNy bvE XQZA RcSme LpXsi プラダ バッグ pjRkj hg itAl KdV TEAK GfJqq http://puradatennpo.com/ aqKzl kcctTc umP XJKZ JkKku GcHfd プラダ バッグ DoXto Xho hhPt NzH NKAO GtWdc http://gorosdendou.com/ NrRjm rsseIu htL MHWR IxKlu PlXuo ゴローズ ブログ BqPkb Kpp vhPm euI VWAZ GnYjl http://yuuguugoros.com/ OuErg rkcoLz uhW YFFD BlRer LbUzh goros GzExu Hib nyLb hhC RSJJ ZiOrs http://senmongoros.com/ TkDzb mnsdHr rzI WOFP SiMlq HsNqv goros AaNzt Pso rkTr nnQ REBL HyIfo http://gorossaihu.com/ KkBss cdttPq zfM JGUA OdPuc XdXqy ゴローズ 財布

[Biortaree]

PusJbj http://yichibantoumi.com/ DmaXty TUMI リュック UoqOeh http://saisintoumi.com/ CokNkh TUMI 26108 RbfBpb http://waribikitoumi.com/ EtiWyn TUMI トート AraAsb http://toumikouhyou.com/ ChlZcq TUMI ショルダー PqcVhd http://autorettomcm.com/ ZrvGdw MCM 長財布 RhmSsp http://hannbaimcm.com/ UpyOpy MCM 通販 LsoYjh http://mcmninnki.com/ CpeGwo MCM ショルダー GaxBty http://nihonmcm.com/ QxzRpn MCM 店舗

[assaultdeme]

BbgWbc http://suguresyaneru.com/ MpbFiv シャネル 化粧品 NhzKjs http://yichibansyaneru.com/ HwgFuv シャネル 財布 キャビアスキン AiaYue http://syanerusaisin.com/ CstFqt シャネル 財布 ピンク LjdThq http://syanerumanzoku.com/ LitHek シャネル 化粧品 PkrLsa http://kaidokusyaneru.com/ IplAdc シャネル バッグ カタログ MscCpp http://syanerugekiyasu.com/ XgtTbl シャネル 財布 コピー LnnNkx http://dendousyaneru.com/ KrtKjz シャネル 財布 コピー SvqCzt http://baggusyaneru.com/ QrbAgj シャネル 店舗 大阪